“Carolina Caroline” is a Sweaty, Southern Gothic Crime Spree
A life of crime has been a point of fascination and romance throughout time. To be on the run and beyond the confines of traditional society is like chasing freedom in the truest sense of the word. To do so with a pretty partner on your arm is something else entirely. Even though we all know the outcome of Bonnie and Clyde, people still want a taste of what popular culture has told us they had. Director Adam Carter Rehmeier and writer William Thomas Dean IV’s Carolina Caroline have created a new version of what love on the run looks like.
Caroline (Samara Weaving) has the sort of mundane, run-of-the-mill life one might expect from a gas station attendant in rural Texas. She’s stocking shelves one day when a handsome guy in rugged jeans and a bright white t-shirt comes in. He runs a short-change scam on the guy working the register, but Caroline catches on. She follows him out to his car and confronts him. He tells her his name is Oliver (Kyle Gallner), and the sparks fly between them. It doesn’t take long for Caroline to find herself in his passenger seat, doing cons of her own.
Courtesy of Magnolia Pictures
Much like Bonnie and Clyde, we have a pretty good feeling about how Caroline and Oliver are going to end. One could argue that they both suspect the eventual outcome of their exploits, but they want to believe in the possibility of another ending, and so too does the audience. The chemistry between Caroline and Oliver is exactly what it needs to be for this Southern Gothic crime story. The audience needs to understand why Caroline, a young woman with a good head on her shoulders, would pick up and leave everything for this con man passing through town. It doesn’t hurt that Oliver has boyish good looks, but what really captures Caroline are his adventurous spirit and his ability to have an intellectual conversation about morality and the ethics of what he’s doing. That alone is more of a thrill than she likely ever got in her rural Texan town.
“There is no lie more convincing than the one we tell ourselves,” Oliver says to Caroline. Much of Carolina Caroline is a series of lies, both outward and inward. The film’s title comes from Caroline’s desire to go to South Carolina to find her mom (Kyra Sedgwick), who left her as a child. Caroline tells herself that finding her mom will mean something. She has to believe that. Even though all the signs in life point to her mom wanting nothing to do with her, Caroline needs a guiding light. When that is brutally extinguished, she spirals. It’s the internal lies that do the most damage to the soul.
Courtesy of Magnolia Pictures
Carolina Caroline is Weaving’s third theatrical release of 2026. From Ready or Not 2: Here I Come to Over Your Dead Body and now Carolina Caroline, Weaving has been busy. There are similarities between Ready or Not 2 and Over Your Dead Body, but Carolina Caroline stands out in her filmography as work that’s a little more grounded. Weaving became a household name for getting covered in blood and screaming in rage, which she does marvelously, but Carolina Caroline allows her to dial back and use smaller actions to convey as much as her primal screams did in the Ready or Not franchise.
In a bittersweet moment toward the end of the film, Caroline and Oliver are dancing, holding each other close. He says, “How did we get here?” Her reply is simple. “You walked into my filling station.” Perhaps that’s the lovers-on-the-run equivalent of “Of all the gin joints in all the world…” Carolina Caroline is sweaty, steamy, and savory, a road trip whose end is known, but whose journey lights a fire.
Follow me on BlueSky, Instagram, Letterboxd, TikTok, YouTube, & Facebook. Check out Movies with My Dad, a podcast recorded on the car ride home from the movies and I Think You’ll Hate This, a podcast hosted by two friends who rarely agree.
support your local film critic!
~
support your local film critic! ~
Beyond the Cinerama Dome is run by one perpetually tired film critic
and her anxious emotional support chihuahua named Frankie.
Your kind donation means Frankie doesn’t need to get a job…yet.