“The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping” Lacks the Anger of Earlier Installments

Author Suzanne Collins published The Hunger Games in 2008. In the eighteen years since, she has published four more novels and there have been six feature film adaptations of her work. The most recent film is a prequel: The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping. It takes place twenty-four years before the events of the first film/book and centers on Haymitch Abernathy. He was introduced to the world of The Hunger Games as a drunkard mentor to District 12 tributes Katniss Everdeen and Peeta Mellark. One can only become a mentor after winning the Games themselves, and as such, Sunrise on the Reaping is the story of Haymitch’s Games.

Haymitch (Joseph Zada) has the unfortunate coincidence of having been born on the day of the reaping. Today is Haymitch’s sixteenth birthday and the reaping for the 50th Hunger Games. The reigning Capitol makes these anniversary Games especially violent in new ways for each of the Quarter Quells. For the Second Quarter Quell, the Capitol will be reaping four tributes instead of two, doubling the number of children in the Games to forty-eight. At first, Haymitch is in the clear. Two other boys have been reaped, Wyatt Callow (Ben Wang) and Woodbine Chance (Serafin Mishiev), but Woodbine decides to make an escape. He’s gunned down immediately, and in the ensuing scuffle with Peacekeepers, Haymitch is selected to take in Woodbine’s place.

Courtesy of Murray Close

In a series predicated on kids killing each other, it seems strange to enjoy getting a chance to see some of the characters from the original series as they would have been decades younger. The previous prequel, The Hunger Games: The Ballad of Songbirds & Snakes, already gave deeper insight into the psyche of President Snow. Originally played by Donald Sutherland, then by Tom Blyth in the prequel, and now by Ralph Fiennes, the progression of Snow makes for a deeply compelling villain arc. Through all the films, despite some physical differences, the looming, overwhelming essence of Snow comes across in all performances. Of course, Snow isn’t the only returning character. Some fan favorites like Wiress, Beetee, Mags, Effie Trinket, Plutarch Heavensbee, and Caesar Flickman all return with different actors. Most of these performances are like Fiennes’ in that they carry the essence of the actors who came before them, but it’s Kieran Culkin as Caesar Flickerman who doesn’t connect a clear line from Culkin to Stanley Tucci.

Sunrise on the Reaping is about Haymitch trying and failing to start a revolution. In the beginning of the film, he’s resigned to the fact that the Reaping is happening now, so it will happen forever. His girlfriend, Lenore Dove (Whitney Peak), tells him that nothing is inevitable. That becomes his guiding principle as he’s presented with a chance to rebel and potentially break the Games. It doesn’t feel like a spoiler to say that his efforts do not work and the Games continue for another twenty-five years, given the fact that Collins published these stories out of order, but it does show how long it takes to inflict lasting change. Change does not happen overnight. Katniss’ spark of rebellion caught fire because of the kindling of hope laid by Haymitch and all the subsequent people who tried to overthrow the Capitol. This idea is best summed up by Plutarch (Jesse Plemons) toward the end of the film. It may take generations to see the world they’re fighting for, but they can only get there by trying to destroy the machine.

Courtesy of Murray Close/Lionsgate

Of all the Hunger Games films, Sunrise on the Reaping feels slightly more disconnected from the violence of these Games. It’s still sad and heartbreaking, but what turned these books and movies into the phenomenon they are is the emotional connections to these characters. Sunrise on the Reaping has too many characters and too many narrative intricacies to juggle in a film. Not only does the script need to bring back the characters from the earlier books, but the number of Tributes in the Arena has doubled, and most of them are faceless to the audience. It’s an example of the format not matching the story’s needs. In the book, there’s much more development between Haymitch and one of the girl Tributes from District 12, Maysilee Donner (Mckenna Grace), who is seen as a selfish girl back home. In fact, there are many changes between the film and the book that tone down the severity of what Collins initially wrote. Call me crazy, but a story built on a tyrannical government that forces children to fight each other for sport, entertainment, and punishment shouldn’t be watered down for an easier watch.


Follow me on BlueSky, Instagram, Letterboxd, TikTok, YouTube, & Facebook. Check out Movies with My Dad, a podcast recorded on the car ride home from the movies.

support your local film critic!

~

support your local film critic! ~

Beyond the Cinerama Dome is run by one perpetually tired film critic
and her anxious emotional support chihuahua named Frankie.
Your kind donation means Frankie doesn’t need to get a job…yet.

3% Cover the Fee
Next
Next

3RFF: Jonn Herschend Sees Each Viewer as a Collaborator in “Lenka and Phillip Collect Tongs”