SXSW ’26: Is it Suicide or Murder at the heart of “Kill Me”
Mental illness is a beast. It’s so easy to think about resting a twisted ankle or a broken leg, but a mind that’s struggling is treated differently. Because we can’t see it or touch it, people often think it’s a lesser problem, but that’s completely inaccurate. Anyone who has struggled with anxiety, depression, or any other mental health issue will tell you that while it may be invisible, it can still pack a wallop. In his directorial debut, writer/director Peter Warren externalizes the internal in the SXSW-premiering Kill Me. Part murder mystery, part comedy, Kill Me is a wholly unique beast, much like mental illness.
Jimmy (Charlie Day) wakes from a stupor in a bathtub filled with his own blood. His wrists are slit and he’s fading in and out of consciousness. He manages to get 911 on the line and Margot, the dispatcher (Allison Williams), sends help his way. When Jimmy wakes up in the hospital, he’s adamant that he didn’t try to commit suicide. He says that someone else slit his wrists to make it look like a suicide when it was, in fact, a murder attempt. No one believes Jimmy because he has attempted suicide in the past, but revelations seem to indicate that he might not be so crazy after all. With the concerned, begrudging help of Margot, Jimmy dedicates himself to figuring out who tried to kill him.
People like to say the mind plays tricks, but that minimizes the extent to which our brains can inflict harm on us. Kill Me meticulously bounces between proof that Jimmy is right and proof that he needs serious psychiatric care. It’s a high-wire act that Warren set up. Within scenes, the audience moves back and forth between belief and disbelief. It’s this belief, or lack thereof, that speaks to the endlessly circling prison of mental illness. There’s always just a little more proof needed to quell the voices in your head, but nothing will ever be sufficient. Anxiety and depression thrive on uncertainty and chow down on it the way Jimmy eats his beloved green sauce from the Cuban place that’s essential to his investigation. Without doubt, fear, or isolation, anxiety and depression have no power. The problem is that when someone is in the thick of depression, it’s a fog so dense it’s impossible to see the forest for the trees. How do you solve a problem when you might be the problem?
Day is best known for his work on It’s Always Sunny, which is a through-and-through comedy about dirtbags making terrible decisions. Kill Me allows him to go to comedic places he’s never gone before while hurtling toward dramatic moments as well. The monologue when Margot pseudo-interrogates Jimmy as part of their investigation stops the film in its tracks. It’s a marvelous, intimately honest admission of Jimmy’s emotions. At one point, he says, “I’m not crazy, I just need a little help.” The pain in his voice is cavernous, and this small statement says so much about how hard he’s trying to get better and how much of an uphill climb it is to make any headway.
One of the quietly powerful moments of the film is the realization that Margot is also unwell. To work at a 911 call center takes a certain kind of strength, but the audience sees that what’s plaguing Margot goes deeper than that. One of the things Warren mentioned in an interview was the effort made to capture the universal feelings of depression while being specific to Jimmy. The same could be said about Margot. On paper, she looks like she’s more together, but then she drinks vodka out of a Nalgene bottle. That’s not something a person who’s feeling well would do, but it’s also different from Jimmy’s experience.
“So, what? You'd rather be dead?” asks one of Jimmy’s family members. “Sometimes,” he answers, “but not this time.” Warren has created something dazzling with Kill Me. It’s a high-wire act that could only be written and helmed by a man who, by his own admission, has been Jimmy, Margot, and Jimmy’s family at various points in his life. Kill Me is not a whodunnit in the traditional sense, but it mirrors the mysteries that are taking place in the brains of so many people every single day.
Follow me on BlueSky, Instagram, Letterboxd, TikTok, YouTube, & Facebook. Check out Movies with My Dad, a podcast recorded on the car ride home from the movies and I Think You’ll Hate This, a podcast hosted by two friends who rarely agree.
support your local film critic!
~
support your local film critic! ~
Beyond the Cinerama Dome is run by one perpetually tired film critic
and her anxious emotional support chihuahua named Frankie.
Your kind donation means Frankie doesn’t need to get a job…yet.